066: Ep62 – Is the Church Killing God?

Philosophy Bakes Bread radio show & podcast

In this 62nd episode of the Philosophy Bakes Bread radio show and podcast, Eric Thomas Weber and Anthony Cashio interview philosopher and Pentecostal Christian Dr. J. Aaron Simmons on his question: “Is the Church Killing God?”

Dr. J. Aaron Simmons.

Aaron is associate professor of Philosophy at Furman University in Greenville, South Carolina. He works primarily in philosophy of religion and 19th and 20th Century European Philosophy, but also researches political philosophy and environmental philosophy. He has authored a number of books, including God and the Other, The New Phenomenology, Re-examining Deconstruction and Determinate Religion, and Kierkegaard and Levinas: Ethics, Politics, and Religion.

Listen for our “You Tell Me!” questions and for some jokes in one of our concluding segments, called “Philosophunnies.” Reach out to us on Facebook @PhilosophyBakesBread and on Twitter @PhilosophyBB; email us at philosophybakesbread@gmail.com; or call and record a voicemail that we play on the show, at 859.257.1849. Philosophy Bakes Bread is a production of the Society of Philosophers in America (SOPHIA). Check us out online at PhilosophyBakesBread.com and check out SOPHIA at PhilosophersInAmerica.com.

 

(1 hr 20 mins)

Click here for a list of all the episodes of Philosophy Bakes Bread.

 

Notes

  1. William McDonald, “Soren Kierkegaard,” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 1996 / 2017.
  2. Durer’s northern renaissance art, described in The New York Times.
  3. Titian, the painter’s biography.
  4. Wordsworth’s The Prelude, 1850.
  5. Biography of poet Veronica Franco.
  6. St. Augustine of Hippo, on ChristianityToday.com.
  7. Article in The New York Times and another in the Huffington Post crediting St. Augustine with the phrase: “The Church is a whore; but she is my mother.”
  8. Kenosis, Meriam-Webster defines as: “the relinquishment of divine attributes by Jesus Christ in becoming human.” Dr. Simmons uses the word “kenotic,” at one point, referring to this meaning, as the character of such relinquishing.
  9. Michael Tooley, “The Problem of Evil,” The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2002 / 2015.
  10. “Pneumatology,” according to Bible.org, refers to “the study of the biblical doctrine of the Holy Spirit. Generally, this includes such topics as the personality of the Spirit, the deity of the Spirit, and the work of the Spirit throughout Scripture.” Dr. Simmons uses the phrase “Pneumatological imagination,” to refer to thinking that centers on the Holy Spirit.
  11. “Turing machine,” refers to a machine that is made to try to pass as though it is a person, whom you cannot distinguish from a person, in terms of its responses to your interactions with it, assuming you cannot see the machine or imagined person responding. For more information, see David Barker, “Turing Machines,” The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 1995 / 2012.
  12. Dr. Simmons brings up a clever quote, whose source he suggests might have been Mark Twain. The line was: “The first casualty of war is the truth.” The Guardian published a piece which suggests that the earliest version of this line comes from Aeschylus, who wrote that: “In war, truth is the first casualty.” See “Who coined the phrase, ‘The first casualty of War is Truth’?The Guardian.
  13. Acts 2:45, according to Biblehub.org, reads “They sold property and possessions to give to anyone who had need.”
  14. C.S. Lewis, “Learning in Wartime,” on CSLewis.com.
  15. The blog that Aaron co-founded, called “Philosophy Goes to Church.”

 

You Tell Me!

For our future “You Tell Me!” segments, Aaron posed the following question in this episode:

“What are your questions? And, when you encounter someone new, what if you asked them ‘What’s your story?’ and ‘What are your questions?’?”

Let us know what you think! Via TwitterFacebookEmail, or by commenting here below.

065: Ep61 – The Future of Community College Education

Philosophy Bakes Bread radio show & podcast

Dr. Cliff Harbour.In this sixty-first episode of the Philosophy Bakes Bread radio show and podcast, the second that aired in 2018, co-hosts Eric Thomas Weber and Anthony Cashio interview Dr. Cliff Harbour on “The Future of Community College Education,” the theme of his 2015 book, John Dewey and the Future of Community College Education.

The front of a community college building, on which the words were edited to read: 'The Future of Community College Education.'

Chemeketa Community College, Creative commons license.

Cliff is Professor of Counseling and Higher Education at the University of North Texas, which he joined in 2017. From 2008 until this move, he taught at the University of Wyoming, and before that at Colorado State University. He has an impressive philosophical background, having majored in Philosophy as an undergraduate, before studying the law. After that, he headed to Duke University for his master’s degree in Philosophy, and then completed his doctorate in education at North Carolina State University.

Listen for our “You Tell Me!” questions and for some jokes in one of our concluding segments, called “Philosophunnies.” Reach out to us on Facebook @PhilosophyBakesBread and on Twitter @PhilosophyBB; email us at philosophybakesbread@gmail.com; or call and record a voicemail that we play on the show, at 859.257.1849. Philosophy Bakes Bread is a production of the Society of Philosophers in America (SOPHIA). Check us out online at PhilosophyBakesBread.com and check out SOPHIA at PhilosophersInAmerica.com.



(1 hr 5 mins)

Click here for a list of all the episodes of Philosophy Bakes Bread.

 

The cover of Cliff Harbour's book, 'John Dewey and the Future of Community College Education,' featuring John Dewey. Notes

  1. Cliff Harbour, John Dewey and the Future of Community College Education (London: Bloomsbury Academic Publishers, 2014).
  2. Richard Field, “John Dewey,” Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
  3. Fast Facts on Completion Rates,” the National Center for Education Statistics.

 

You Tell Me!

For our future “You Tell Me!” segments, Cliff posed the following question in this episode:

“Where do you see philosophy reflected, displayed, exhibited in the arts, like literature and film?”

Let us know what you think! Via TwitterFacebookEmail, or by commenting here below.

On Thursday, March 22nd at 8pm U.S. Eastern Time, SOPHIA is holding our next online symposium, on “Plato’s Cave Today.” Join us!

Photo of Dr. Anthony Cashio.Anthony Cashio will be our facilitator for this event. This meeting will be about the content of our very first episode of Philosophy Bakes Bread, but there is no homework to prepare in advance of this meeting. If you want to listen to the episode, you’re encouraged to do it, but we will proceed with the assumption that some or many have not had a chance to hear it.

SOPHIA aims to hold genuinely conversational meetings. We have a facilitator or two each time, but the idea is not to hear a presentation and then ask questions, but instead to have a very brief introduction to a topic, give everyone sufficient time to read our one-sheet document for this event, and then we open the floor to discussion about it.

Thumbnail photo of a one-sheet document.Thursday’s meeting will be about difficulties obtaining and knowing the truth, about the ways in which media frame our understanding of facts, and about the challenges that emerge as a result for trusting politicians, journalists, scientists, and others. At the same time, trust is important and yet ideals of objectivity may well be unattainable. We will have fun talking about these topics, going where our conversation takes us.

To prepare for an online symposium, please be sure to:

a) situate yourself in a quiet space (or else the moderator will mute your microphone)

b) have a working Web cam, microphone, and headphones (otherwise, your mic may pick up your speakers)

c) be connected to a great internet connection

d) pause or turn off file-syncing software, like Dropbox, Google Drive, iCloud, etc.

e) mute phones

f) Know that we will be recording this event and posting it on YouTube and on our Web site. Participation is taken to be permission to be recorded.

 

Photo of SOPHIA's first online philosophical conversation, on trigger warnings.We’ll be connecting via:

Zoom Video conferencing using this link: 

https://uky.zoom.us/j/249753269

Date: March 22, 2018
Time: 08:00-9:30 p.m.
Event: Plato's Cave Today: Online Symposium
Sponsor: The Society of Philosophers in America (SOPHIA)
859.257.1849
Venue: Zoom Video Conferencing Platform
Public: Public

If you haven't already done so, consider joining the Society of Philosophers in America (SOPHIA)!

The Molemen & Plato’s Cave Today

One-sheet for SOPHIA Conversations

Adobe logo, to serve as a link to the Adobe PDF version of the one-sheet.

Printable PDF.

Here is our one-sheet document on “The Molemen and Plato’s Cave Today.” For short, you can just call it “Plato’s Cave Today.” The idea is to think about problems for conceiving of truth and knowledge, which lead to difficulties in trusting politicians, news sources, scientists, and more. Plato’s famous cave metaphor is explained in short for anyone who’s unfamiliar, and we invite chapters to pick a question that they’d most like to talk about together. After thinking about it and perhaps another for a time, flip over the page and consider the “Bread Breaking Questions,” questions about how and where the concepts discussed so far are sometimes applied and with challenges.

A drawing of Plato's Cave, featuring prisoners on the left, looking at the left wall of a cave, with fire behind them and puppeteers behind a wall between the inmates and the fire.

Thumbnail photo of a one-sheet document.This one-sheet document is part of a series to come of one-sheets about episodes of Philosophy Bakes Bread. We’re calling them “Slices of Philosophically Baked Bread.” It would be great if local SOPHIA Chapter participants had the chance to listen to episodes of Philosophy Bakes Bread (such as this one, Episode 1 of the show), but we try to avoid requiring homework before people come to our events.

Instead, we want to ensure that everyone has a document that is one sheet of paper (front and back sometimes) that each person can read at the start of the event in a few minutes. Then, conversation can open up with everyone literally on the same page.

James LincolnJames William Lincoln has kindly taken on the job of creating our one-sheet documents for each episode of Philosophy Bakes Bread. We’ll be posting and cataloging one-sheets on other matters and topics, such as on pieces published in Civil American, plus we plan to post one-sheets that our members and chapter leaders gather or create.

If you have ideas for future one-sheet documents that could be great for SOPHIA to use in our chapter meetings, let us know! Email Executive Director Eric Thomas Weber with your idea.

‘It’s Over Debbie’ – Euthanasia

One-Sheet for SOPHIA Conversations

John Lachs facilitating a SOPHIA symposium in Oxford, MS.

John Lachs of Vanderbilt University

This piece was published in the Journal of the American Medical Association in 1988 and inspired a firestorm of responses. Dr. John Lachs proposed this as a one-sheet document for a conversation that he and Executive Director Weber organized in Oxford, MS, in 2008 on “Ethics at the End of Life.” This one-sheet document was hugely successful for spurring inspired yet civil conversation about values at the end of life, as well as whether there should be freedom in end-of-life decision-making, what sort, and what kinds of policies make sense for end-of-life circumstances. The JAMA withheld the name of the author this piece by request.

Adobe logo, to serve as a link to the Adobe PDF version of the piece.

Printable PDF.

The document is available on the JAMA Web site as an image file. For a printable, searchable (OCR’d) version, click here, on the Adobe PDF logo on right, or on the image here below:

An image of a portion of the piece published in the Journal of the American Medical Association, titled 'It's Over Debbie.' This image links to a printable, searchable (OCR'd) version of this file as a PDF.